MODEL DIAGNOSTIC DISCUSSION
NWS HYDROMETEOROLOGICAL PREDICTION CENTER CAMP SPRINGS MD
145 PM EST WED DEC 23 2009
VALID DEC 23/1200 UTC THRU DEC 27/0000 UTC
...SEE NOUS42 KWNO ADMNFD FOR THE STATUS OF THE UPPER AIR
INGEST...
FINAL 12Z MODEL EVALUATION INCLUDING THE ECMWF
MODEL INITIALIZATION ERRORS DO NOT APPEAR TO HAVE A SIGNIFICANT
IMPACT ON THE FORECAST.
...TROF APPROACHING THE WEST COAST ON SAT...
PREFERENCE: 12Z GFS/ECMWF COMPROMISE
BY THE END OF THE FCST PERIOD LATE SAT THE NAM IS FASTER THAN THE
GFS IN BRINGING MID LVL ENERGY TO THE PAC NW COAST. THE GFS/NAM
ARE MORE SIMILAR WITH WEAK ENERGY REACHING CA AND VICINITY. BOTH
THE NAM AND GFS HAVE BEEN INCONSISTENT WITH THE HANDLING OF THE
OVERALL SHRTWV DURING THE PAST 12-24 HRS... BUT THE FACT THAT THE
00Z ECMWF/UKMET/CMC RUNS AND 09Z SREF/06Z-12Z GEFS/00Z ECMWF
ENSEMBLE MEANS ALL SHOW A SHRTWV ORIENTATION SIMILAR TO THE 12Z
GFS OFFERS A DECENT DEGREE OF CONFIDENCE THAT THE GFS SCENARIO IS
MORE LIKELY. STRENGTH OF THE WRN NOAM MEAN RIDGE ALSO SUGGESTS
THAT ANY ENERGY REACHING THE WEST COAST SHOULD EITHER FLOW FARTHER
SWD THAN THE NAM AS IT UNDERCUTS THE RIDGE OR ELSE BE DEFLECTED
AROUND THE WRN PART OF THE RIDGE. 12Z UKMET/CANADIAN GLBL RUNS
HAVE BROUGHT THE CORE OF MID LVL ENERGY FARTHER SWD THAN THE
DOMINANT CLUSTER OF GUIDANCE BY LATE SAT. THE 12Z ECMWF HAS
ADJUSTED A LITTLE SLOWER/SWD AS WELL BUT NOT TO THE EXTENT OF THE
UKMET/CMC. PREFERRING TO WAIT FOR FURTHER CONFIRMATION ON A SOLN
AS SLOW/CLOSED AS THE UKMET/CMC... WILL RECOMMEND A GFS/ECMWF
COMPROMISE.
...DEEPENING STORM TRACKING ACROSS THE CNTRL CONUS...PREFERENCE: SFC... CANADIAN GLBL/ECMWF/12Z GEFS MEAN THRU F30 MID
THU FOLLOWED BY A NAM AND 12Z/00Z ECMWF COMPROMISE... ALOFT NAM
AND 12Z/00Z ECMWF COMPROMISE THRU THE PERIODBY THU THE GFS SHOWS EARLIER DEEPENING AND FARTHER WWD TRACK OF
THE EVOLVING SFC LOW COMPARED TO THE NAM. THE GFS/NAM CONVERGE
DEPTH-WISE BY F48 EARLY FRI WITH THE GFS POSITIONING THE LOW SWD
OF THE NAM. AFTER EARLY FRI THE NAM PULLS THE SFC LOW FARTHER WWD
THAN THE GFS... WITH THE NAM REMAINING WWD OF THE GFS FOR THE
REMAINDER OF THE FCST. SFC DIFFS CORRESPOND TO THE GFS BECOMING
DEEPER THAN THE NAM WITH THE CORE OF THE MID LVL SYSTEM CROSSING
THE SRN PLAINS ON THU... AND TRACKING THE CORE OF UPSTREAM ALBERTA
CLOSED LOW ENERGY FARTHER SWD/SEWD THAN THE NAM.
REMAINING MODEL/ENSEMBLE GUIDANCE CONTINUES TO SHOW SOME
MEANINGFUL SPREAD IN DETAILS OF SYSTEM EVOLUTION. WHAT CONSENSUS
EXISTS... NOW INCLUDING THE 12Z ECMWF AND GEFS MEAN... INDICATES
THAT THE GFS MAY BE EXCESSIVELY DEEP WITH ITS MID LVL SYSTEM
TRACKING ACROSS THE SRN PLAINS INTO MO... RESULTING IN A
DEEPER/WWD GFS SFC LOW THU INTO THU NIGHT. THE UKMET/GEFS MEAN DO
SHOW POTENTIAL FOR THE SFC LOW TO TRACK WWD OF THE NAM IN THIS
TIME FRAME THOUGH. MEANWHILE THE GFS/GEFS MEAN MAY BRING THE
ALBERTA CLOSED LOW ALOFT TOO FAR SWD INTO THE PLAINS. SLOWER GFS
TREND OVER THE PAST DAY WITH THIS FEATURE OFFERS ADDED SUPPORT FOR
THE NON-GFS CONSENSUS. ON THE OTHER HAND BEST CONSENSUS INDICATES
THAT THE NAM MAY BE SLIGHTLY WEAK AT THE SFC AS OF F24 EARLY
THU... BUT COMPARES BETTER BY LATER IN THE DAY. THEN THE NAM IS
ON THE WRN EDGE OF THE GUIDANCE SPREAD ESPECIALLY AROUND LATE FRI.
EXACTLY HOW FAR WWD THE SFC LOW TRACKS WILL DEPEND ON LOW
CONFIDENCE SHRTWV DETAILS TYPICALLY NOT WELL RESOLVED 2-3 DAYS OUT
IN TIME... SO PARTIAL WEIGHTING OF THE NAM COULD BE WARRANTED.
WITH THE PREVIOUS TWO MAJOR SYSTEMS AFFECTING CNTRL/ERN AREAS SOME
NAM RUNS HAD TRACKS ON THE EXTREME WRN SIDE OF THE SOLN ENVELOPE
WITH VERIFICATION ON AVERAGE SUGGESTING A SOLN PARTIALLY BUT NOT
COMPLETELY TO THE NAM COULD OFFER THE BEST TRACK DURING THE TIME
THAT THE NAM IS ON THE WRN EDGE OF GUIDANCE. THE GFS LEANS TO THE
ERN SIDE OF THE SOLN SPREAD BY SAT.
THE 12Z ECMWF HAS TRENDED SLOWER WITH THE SFC LOW DURING THU INTO
EARLY FRI... AND TRENDS WWD OF THE 00Z RUN AROUND LATE FRI/FRI
NIGHT. THIS ADJUSTMENT STILL LEAVES THE NAM AS THE FARTHEST WWD
SOLN AT THAT TIME BUT TO A LESSER EXTENT. MEANWHILE THE 12Z ECMWF
MAINTAINS CONTINUITY SIMILAR TO CONSENSUS NWD OF THE GFS WITH THE
ALBERTA UPPER LOW TRACKING SEWD INTO THE PLAINS. STRENGTH OF
UPSTREAM FLOW LEAVES SOME DOUBT ABOUT THE SLOWER 12Z ECMWF TREND
THU-THU NIGHT... AND THE UPPER LOW MAY BE A LITTLE DEEP FRI-SAT...
BUT AS A WHOLE MOST 12Z ECMWF ATTRIBUTES ARE SUFFICIENTLY
REASONABLE TO GIVE PARTIAL WEIGHTING.
AS THE SYSTEM TRACKS THRU THE SRN PLAINS THRU F30 MID THU...
MODEL/ENSEMBLE MEAN CONSENSUS THAT IS DEEPER THAN THE NAM BUT
WEAKER THAN THE GFS FAVORS A SOLN CLOSEST TO THE CANADIAN
GLBL/ECMWF/GEFS MEAN. HOWEVER NOTE THAT THE GEFS MEAN IS FARTHER
SWD THAN OPERATIONAL CONSENSUS INCLUDING THE GFS WITH THE UPSTREAM
UPPER LOW TRACKING INTO THE NRN PLAINS. THE CANADIAN GLBL SFC
TRACK IS ON THE SERN EDGE OF GUIDANCE BY LATE THU... BUT THE 12Z
ECMWF IS FAIRLY CLOSE AS WELL. FROM LATE THU ONWARD WILL
RECOMMEND A NAM AND 12Z/00Z ECMWF BLEND WEIGHTED EVENLY AMONG
THOSE THREE SOURCES AS THE BEST REPRESENTATION OF MAJORITY
GUIDANCE CLUSTERING WHILE MAINTAINING OPERATIONAL MODEL DETAILS
THAT GET SMOOTHED OUT SOMEWHAT IN THE ENSEMBLE MEANS. THIS NAM
AND 12Z/00Z ECMWF BLEND IS RECOMMENDED ALOFT FOR THE ENTIRE
PERIOD.
...WAVE LIFTING NWD ALONG THE EAST COAST FRI ONWARD...
PREFERENCE: 12Z/00Z ECMWF COMPROMISE
THE NAM BECOMES SLOWER THAN THE GFS WITH THE NWD PROGRESSION OF
THE WAVE... AS THE NAM IS MORE AMPLIFIED THAN THE GFS WITH THE
UPSTREAM TROF AND SLOWER WITH EWD PROGRESSION OF LEADING HGT
FALLS. MOST OTHER MODEL/ENSEMBLE SOLNS RECOMMEND A COMPROMISE
BETWEEN THE GFS AND NAM EXTREMES. THE 00Z/12Z CANADIAN GLBL RUNS
ARE BOTH ABOUT AS FAST AS THE GFS THRU F72 EARLY SAT BUT THE 12Z
CMC TRENDS SLOWER THEREAFTER AND THE UKMET FALLS INTO THE MIDDLE
OF THE GUIDANCE SPREAD. THE 12Z ECMWF IS SLIGHTLY FASTER THAN THE
PREVIOUS RUN LATE FRI-FRI NIGHT BUT OTHERWISE IS CONSISTENT WITH
ITS PREVIOUS RUN. PREFER AN AVERAGE OF THE 12Z/00Z ECMWF RUNS AS
A GOOD INTERMEDIATE SOLN WHICH ALSO TAKES INTO ACCOUNT GENERALLY
FAVORABLE ECMWF HANDLING OF THE UPSTREAM SYSTEM.
...UPPER LOW DEPARTING FROM NEW ENGLAND...
THE GFS/NAM AND OTHER MODEL/ENSEMBLE SOLNS SHOW ONLY MINOR TIMING
DIFFS WHICH DO NOT APPEAR TO HAVE A MEANINGFUL IMPACT ON SENSIBLE
WEATHER OVER THE NORTHEAST.
...MODEL TREND GRAPHICS AT
http://WWW.HPC.NCEP.NOAA.GOV/HTML/MODEL2.SHTML...
...500MB FORECASTS AT
http://WWW.HPC.NCEP.NOAA.GOV/H5PREF/H5PREF.SHTML...
RAUSCH