Ntxw wrote:orangeblood wrote:Ntxw wrote:
It's a combination of things. Not too much model support, and frankly uninteresting runs overnight partially.
Second people are now starting to leave for their trips so postings might be limited.
Third, as mentioned the cynicism and pessimism often deters posters from discussing things beyond. As I said before, it's bled from the tropical threads and persons who posts something to discuss down the road potential can feel discouraged to share when flooded with "always 10 days out, not real etc etc." That's how a thread dies when discussion is not progressive.
I agree, things need to stay positive and progressive around here but when your forecasting resources are essentially worthless past 7 days, it is difficult to make these medium to long range discussions more than just pure fantasy. But I guess that is winter life below the 35 N parallel
Models will be models, always will be. What I fear is we don't end up in the rabbit hole that discussion will fall off as discussions become less progressive and more antagonizing. At the point what is the purpose of a winter thread to discuss winter weather? Might as well just do as the Florida folks with one long thread for all seasons if discussion is limited right? Next 10 days 70 and sunny, cold runs fantasy talk.
I have been thinking about this thread and how it can be improved, if at all. I don't have a good solution though. I had thought of having a separate model thread like we have for the Tropics, and each different organized tropical system. Some of the problem I see is that when these long range, fantasy models are posted that show any kind of wintry precip in Texas, it does spurn some discussions. But its mostly facetious discussion since everyone pretty much knows better than to buy into it. Which then makes me wonder, why post the model in the 1st place? But since this is the Winter thread, there is a legitimacy to posting it, despite the fact it will likely never happen.
I look at the recent discussions where the models were consistently showing cold temps and wintry precip in the timeframe we're in now. I remember posters posting how many runs in a row this was being shown, but as we see it doesn't matter because it won't materialize. This is another legitimate discussion to have here. But the nature of where we live, and how difficult it is to get wintry precip is going to make most of the model runs just something pretty to look at, and fantasize over. I don't have a good answer for this other than this is the nature of where we live, and posters need to realize it takes a lot to get wintry precip here, these events are not common; sorta like hurricanes affecting the Northeast. It happens, just not that often.