Or neither existed? I just looked through my "North Carolina's Hurricane History" book (published by Jay Barnes) and found no mention of either storm...and looking at the track, I would of expected some mention of damage somewhere from Eastern NC, considering the fact that it practicly brushed us...But not even a mere sentence on them, skips from 1885ish to 1893.
Edit: Checked another source and found this:
August 20, 1887
Damage was heavy from this severe hurricane which was first spotted several hundred miles northeast of Puerto Rico on the 16th, then moved rapidly along practically the classic path, passing east of Hatters on the 20th. Maximum five-minute wind was 82 mph at Hatteras. The storm was said to have been severe in the Pamlico Sound area, where many vessels were lost and houses blown down. News dispatches concerning this storm ranged from flippant "We had an elegant breeze last night. Some extreme southern friends became excited. Others thought the breeze superb" (from Morehead City) to (two days later) "The storm of Saturday did great damage to the coast." The anemometer blew away at Kitty Hawk, where the observer stated that the fury of the storm was indescrible. As was usually the case when a hurricane struck or passed nearby, the Outer Banks telegraph line was damaged, so that little or no information came from that area for at least several days.
Another storm followed nearly the same path a few days later, but lay somewhat farther offshore and so had much less effect on land areas.
Apparently, they are two seperate storms.