Thunder44 wrote:cycloneye wrote:Thunder maybe they are debating if it is subtropical or tropical?
No, they seem to be agree that tropical in the TWO. I think they took look to come up with a forecast.
They call it tropical because there was a big stink last year about sub-tropical cyclones. To avoid the confusion for those who don't know any better (and really...it's only a big deal to mets...to the average joe the effects are the same)...they call them tropical. However, if you look at the data...it has a lot of hybrid characteristics.
1) Large wind field. Edited to add: Especially one that is well removed from the center. If you look at the buoy reports...the strongest winds are east of Jax and Georgia. Winds within 40 miles of the center are not that bad at all.
2) Area of low pressure moved 200+ miles in 7 hours...towards an area that did not have a deep convective burst...but rather a nice area of diffluence aloft on the east side of a low (like you would see in a baroclinic system).
3) It's on the east side of an upper low with about 20-30 knots zipping over the top of it...and it's still deepening...which means only one thing...baroclinic deepening of the low.
4) To expand on the above: The system is deepning without a lot of convection near the center...and all the heavy convection is well east. That means the process of deepening is occuring in some other way that is not tropical (if it was tropical/barotropic deepening we would see lots of convection right over the center).
5) If you look on radar...it has a tail
6) If you didn't know it was Tammy...and looked at Satallite not knowing what time of year it was...you would think it was some sort of extratropical low.
It certainly isn't purely tropical...if it was...the pressure center would not have jumped 200 miles into an area with no deep convection and it would not be deepening with 20-30 knots of shear over it.
But...the bottom line is the diff b/w a hybrid and a truly tropical storm is only important to the meteorological discussion...not to the effects. So...the only peopole who really care are 1) Mets...and 2) People who really want a tropical system and can't stand the idea that what they are getting is not a true tropical storm









