American Idol

Josephine96 · #141 Postby **Josephine96** » Thu Apr 28, 2005 6:04 pm

Something is up over at AI..

2 weeks in a row.. someone who should have stayed.. went home..

I would have put Constantine in my bottom 3 last night.. but not Vonzell or Anthony..

My bottom 3 last night would have been Scott, Carrie and Constantine..

Something is up with this show.. If it somehow turns into a Scott or Anthony in the final.. I WILL NEVER WATCH THE SHOW AGAIN!

I am a bit past agitated right now lol

DoctorHurricane2003 · #142 Postby **DoctorHurricane2003** » Thu Apr 28, 2005 6:09 pm

Anthony has gotten a lot better actually...a LOT I wouldn't be surprised to see him work his way into final....and this is coming from someone who wanted him gone a while back.

Scott is the one who needs to go NOW. He just sucks! There is no reason for him to be getting these votes! arrrgh!

Who I want to be in the final three:
Vonzell Solomon
Bo Bice
Carrie Underwood

Final two is hard to pick from those three, but I think Bo will definitely be in it......the other two is a toss up depending on their fan base.

Josephine96 · #143 Postby **Josephine96** » Thu Apr 28, 2005 6:12 pm

I would like a Bo and Vonzell final

ohiostorm · #144 Postby **ohiostorm** » Thu Apr 28, 2005 9:31 pm

Underwood is still my girl!

#145 Postby **pojo** » Fri Apr 29, 2005 4:55 pm

Scott has warn out his welcome... he should have gone a LONG time ago.... well before Anwar or Constantine.

Constantine's performance was not that good, but he was better than Scott by a long shot... When you take on Creed... it better be good.

Josephine96 · #146 Postby **Josephine96** » Tue May 03, 2005 8:04 pm

So who's going home this week..

Here's my amateur opinion lol..

I liked the performances.. You might be surprised who I think may leave tomorrow..

Carrie Underwood..

I know she seems to be a favorite of everybodies.. But I really think she could be the vulnerable 1.. I think Scott will still be in {God help us lol}

I would like Scott to go home.. But this is becoming 1 crazy competition

#147 Postby **Pburgh** » Tue May 03, 2005 8:07 pm

You know, I kinda liked Scott's performances tonight. Oh well, so much for good taste.

I hate to jink anyone but Bo rocks and Carrie is perfect!!

GalvestonDuck · #148 Postby **GalvestonDuck** » Tue May 03, 2005 8:11 pm

I finally watched an entire episode (something I haven't done since the auditions) and voted.

Here's my take:

Bo - close my eyes and he sounds like Michael Bolton, a voice I couldn't stand in the 80's and can't stand now. And didn't Bolton actually start out as a hard rocker also? In other words, Bo's not for me. I wouldn't buy his album and I'd probably turn off the radio if one of his songs came on.

Vonzell - nothing particularly special in her performances tonight, but she must have done something to get this far. She didn't really grab me, but didn't make me wanna change the channel either. She's unique at least.

Anthony - looked like Clay during the auditions and still reminds me of Clay. Sounds a lot like Nelson or the Sweet brothers from Stryper. He's good, but not my favorite.

Scott - I was all for him in the beginning since his father gave him such grief. But now, he seems took conceited for his own good. And sounds like Aaron Neville most of the time.

Carrie - loved her from the start and still love her...and it's not just because she's a blonde. Well, okay, that's part of it.

But she has talent also. She can play guitar AND sing.

And did you know, she's the first (and only, so far) Idol contestant not born in a hospital?

Okay, SVU's on...gotta go.

DoctorHurricane2003 · #149 Postby **DoctorHurricane2003** » Tue May 03, 2005 8:12 pm

Personal Overview of Tonights Performances/Final Placement Prediction

Anthony Federov- First song was fairly good, but second song was one of my favorites and I don't know WHAT he did to it.

Scott Savol- 'nough said. Actually I think he did better this week and for once, is NOT the worst there. Still a cocky (insert word here), though.

Vonzell Solomon- Very good, but probably not good enough to make it all the way.

Bo Bice- AWESOME!!!! I've never really been a fan of him, thought he was good and all (long hair is a negative too), but tonight he nailed EVERYTHING. Especially the second song...one of my favorites and it sounded EXACTLY like it does on the CD.

Carrie Underwood- Also AWESOME!!!! She nailed everything she sang, and although I wasn't really great fans of the songs she sang, she sang them PERFECTLY and the second song was really beautiful.

Final Placement Predictions:

?. Bo Bice Chance of Winning- 52%
?. Carrie Underwood Chance of Winning- 48%
3. Vonzell Solomon
4. Scott Savol
5. Anthony Fedorov

Dee Bee · #150 Postby **Dee Bee** » Tue May 03, 2005 8:34 pm

A few personal observations --

(a)Anthony: sweet, talented, but out of his league now

(b)Scott's cocky attitude: the key to his demise

(c)Vonzell: Very talented with great stage presence, but probably not
#1-worthy

Which leaves the winner as --
(e)Bo OR Carrie? They're both outstanding, although it's taken me a while to admit it. A tight race right down to the end.

[Having said all this, I'll probably be eating crow tomorrow at this time.... :roll:

]

Josephine96 · #151 Postby **Josephine96** » Tue May 03, 2005 8:51 pm

This surely has been a great but controversial Idol season.. Too much talent.. and the 1's that we wish were still here are being sent home because for some reason.. the others are still in it lol

Yankeegirl · #152 Postby **Yankeegirl** » Tue May 03, 2005 8:53 pm

I am a fan of Carries from day one... I hope she wins...

Lindaloo · #153 Postby **Lindaloo** » Tue May 03, 2005 9:13 pm

Well I hope Scott goes tomorrow.

#154 Postby **vbhoutex** » Tue May 03, 2005 11:04 pm

Bo and Carrie both rocked the house tonight!!! NO one else was worthy of a vote imo. Scott did better than normal, which isn't saying much. He is still at the bottom of my list as he has been for weeks. He is an arrogant #$%^&#%$*^$ imo. He has overcome much in his life, but he has lost my respect of late with his attitude.

Final 2 will be/should be Bo and Carrie. As much as I think Bo deserves the win, I think Carrie will get it and become another Kelly Clarkson-ie keep on producing good music and selling millions and millions of albums even after her first year shine is gone. Besides that she is GEORGEOUS!!!

#155 Postby **azskyman** » Tue May 03, 2005 11:23 pm

David....I remember your comment last week about Carrie/

Carrie sings?

I'm thinking that in a "scientific" vote, Vonzell, Bo, and Carrie should be in the final three.

Scott is an average Joe who keeps finding a way to stick it in your face. Anthony...a really nice guy who has some talent...but is not idol material.

Simon was right on in one comment....

....that the most excellent performers (Bo, in particular), did distance themselves from those who are not....

But anything can happen...

Josephine96 · #156 Postby **Josephine96** » Wed May 04, 2005 5:02 am

I would not be surprised to see Vonzell win.. She has a great voice too.. I also think she's better than Carrie..

Besides... I'm not entirely sure America is ready for a country American Idol since she does sing a lot of country songs..

I know they like having a rock star in Bo..

I wasn't entirely impressed with Carrie last night.. and No I wasn't sleeping in a cave lol..

I would like to see Scott finally go home.. But ya never know with this competition

#157 Postby **vbhoutex** » Wed May 04, 2005 7:05 am

Josephine96 wrote:I would not be surprised to see Vonzell win.. She has a great voice too.. I also think she's better than Carrie..

Besides... I'm not entirely sure America is ready for a country American Idol since she does sing a lot of country songs..

I know they like having a rock star in Bo..

I wasn't entirely impressed with Carrie last night.. and No I wasn't sleeping in a cave lol..
I would like to see Scott finally go home.. But ya never know with this competition

Are you sure? Maybe it was because you had your head underground? She was GREAT last night and I am not talking just her looks!!!!

TexasStooge · #158 Postby **TexasStooge** » Wed May 04, 2005 8:57 am

vbhoutex wrote:Bo and Carrie both rocked the house tonight!!! NO one else was worthy of a vote imo. Scott did better than normal, which isn't saying much. He is still at the bottom of my list as he has been for weeks. He is an arrogant #$%^&#%$*^$ imo. He has overcome much in his life, but he has lost my respect of late with his attitude.

Final 2 will be/should be Bo and Carrie. As much as I think Bo deserves the win, I think Carrie will get it and become another Kelly Clarkson-ie keep on producing good music and selling millions and millions of albums even after her first year shine is gone. Besides that she is GEORGEOUS!!!

You're right, my guesses are also that Bo and carrie will be the final 2.

As for Scotty, any music he should do is Hip-Hop. I mean, what's with all those "gang signs" while he's performing on stage? Give him a hip-hop song, he's all right or as Randy would say "A'ight". Give him any other genre, he's crappy.

#159 Postby **CaptinCrunch** » Wed May 04, 2005 10:02 am

Bo and carrie will be the final 2, and it will be the toughest final yet. It's a tie in my eye's they both will be stars.

cajungal · #160 Postby **cajungal** » Wed May 04, 2005 10:53 am

It seems like every Wednesday night I have to close at work. I don't get off until 9 and don't get home to almost 9:30. So, I have to keep missing the vote off. I am taping it tonight. So, I will watch it when I get home. I just can't decide between Bo and Carrie. It will be a tough race. I think Anthony will be voted off tonight. But, Scott's arrogant attitude might get him voted off. I don't think I can take much more of Scott.

American Idol

Who is online