TV Guide Survivor Finale Commentary:
http://community.tvguide.com/forum.jspa ... =700007958
Survivor: Cook Islands
by Rhoda Charles
December 17, 2006: The Aitu Four
It was the best of times. It was the worst of times. It was a season that certainly had it’s ups and downs, but if Survivor:Cook Islands were a movie, it would be up for an Oscar.
Ladies and gentlemen, for your consideration, I present the best of Cook Island.
The Best Challenges:
Sure, we had a few recycled challenges but someone on that staff got a shot of creativity that brought us some truly innovative, interesting and challenging competitions.
These last two immunity challenges had me literally on the edge of my seat. Squarely in Aitu’s corner, it was near torture seeing Adam as a real threat to an all-Aitu final four.
Ozzy’s come-from-behind win in the spiderweb/puzzle challenge was reality television at its best. It wasn’t even his physical prowess that amazed me the most this time, because I didn’t even know he had a brain until he wowed me with it by solving that compass-rose puzzle.
Then there was the final immunity challenge. I loved that vanishing platform. How nice of Burnett to even the playing field by tailoring the platform to everyone’s foot. Did you notice Becky’s coat-tail dreams drift away when Yul fell into the water? And good for Sundra giving Ozzy a real run for his money. It was at that point that I really wanted her to make final 3 but that dream went up in flames – oh, no it didn’t! More on that later.
The Best Final Four:
The truth be told, I was still holding a little bit of a grudge against Ozzy for his engineering Billy’s ouster way back when. I finally forgave Ozzy when he pushed the idea of a forced tie between Sundra and Becky. That was a very classy and strategic move that took the onus off of him to choose a finalist while making the women duel it out for their place in the finals.
The Best Tribal Counsels:
I didn’t think any tribal counsel could be funnier than Billy’s infamous love connection one but the tears, the snorts and the belly laughs that erupted from me at the hour mark of Sundra and Becky’s fire-making challenge will not soon be forgotten. Jeff should have booted both women out of the competition when Sundra ran out of matches. I can understand the flint being a little challenging but if, after 39 days, you can’t start a fire with a match then you don’t deserve to win the million dollars.
The Best Use of the Hidden Immunity Idol and Exile Island Twists:
All season I wanted to see that idol come into play. Though he didn’t save himself from eviction with it, Yul polled a Romber (Rob and Amber to the uninitiated) by using the idol to his advantage in an unexpected way and changing up the whole game. And the Auit Four using Exile Island as a weapon was fantastic. Sorry Candice.
There were a lot of other little things that went into making this such a great season: A diverse cast, an innovative crew but most of all Burnett’s willingness to switch things up. Having a final three was almost like having Ross Perot in the election. Becky could have split the vote but in the end she didn’t matter. Hell, most of the jury didn’t realize she was a contender choosing instead to question only Yul and Ozzy. Becky didn’t even get one vote!
Little Things:
• “The fire you brought to the game…” It can’t just be me who thought Parvati was coming on to Ozzy as she cast her final vote.
• Why was Nate on crutches at the final Tribal Counsel?
• Even at the reunion, Rebecca still has nothing to say.
• The eye rolling from Adam, Candice and Parvati – so not called for.
• Poor Becky. She thought she played a social game, yet from what we could see she only spoke to Yul.
• Why did Adam feel the need to diss Sundra? “You’re also boring,” he claimed, but she wasn’t even in the finals!
• Jonathon’s rights, there is no villain in Monopoly.
• Sekou’s Survivor song – way to keep yourself relevant in the game, man.
• So Model Boxing is a real profession? Seriously, I think the Aitu Four should get their own show.
Cook Islands, in my mind at least, will go down in history as one of the best Survivor’s ever. It started with a gimmick and ended with a hero. I could try to sum this season up in a word that begins with a Y and ends with an L but I can’t give all the credit to Yul, though he did say it best. “The strongest teams are those that have a diversity of perspective.” The same can be said of Survivor.