the reason people would argue is that this statment makes you sound ignorant of the elevated storm surge threat due to the size of the windfield, and will not be = to the average cat 2 storm, and sure if this were a three at it's current size it would be even worse, but what is the blessing between having your sea front home destoryed under 18 feet of water compared to 22 for those that "get" this storm. or for those that are stuck in 4 feet of water instead of 5 as they try to exit the barrier islands
I disagree...and think you need to drop this argument. The difference in effects if this storm was say, 120mph would be exponential for many. As you said, the huge windfield would come into play, extending much higher destructive winds not only in the center but to those around it, and as you said an increase of storm surge.
Frankly i'd argue your ignorant of my post...not the other way around. The difference may not mean much to people directly in the eyewall but could be a blessing to others around the area. In any case please drop this...no one is ignorant of storm surge.
I see many residents in the Texas area are very sensitive of the disaster nearing them, and that's understandable. Coming from someone who lived through Katrina I can completely relate.