American Idol - Season 8

[lurkey]

http://www.tmz.com/2009/02/17/american- ... kes-again/


#1 it sucked and it was boring. . thank you for agreeing, Simon

#2 good . . . didn't know he was from Kelly Pickler's area of NC . . did the best with what he had

<naps during commericals>

#3 yay! someone who can sing. .. top 10 maybe top 5

*yawns* <goes to beat up D5 in chat>

#4 hmmmm, *makes note "need to hang out Home Depot more."* nice eye candy; not the best song

another commerical?????

<checks the running commentary on Twitter>

#5 wrong song. . . too pitchy

#6 Anoop Dog!!!!!! not too bad; not as good as #3

<thwaps D5 in chat>

#7 bad start. . . ok bad middle and bad in general. . NEXT

<Changes channel> crap .. commercial

#8 mmmm ... . bo bice did this a lot better. . .otherwise I liked it. . .

#9 Katherine McPhee wannabe it was too bad. . .

#10 meh.. .

<gives the production crew a F, the audio sucks badly>

commercial, blah back to chat and twitter

*thwaps D5*


#11 *covers ears* I <3 Simon, sometimes. . . .

<wonders if I should revive D5 after shooting him to put him out of his misery>

*shrugs*

mmmmmm, jack bauer. . . .

#12 one of the best tonight. . . . finally another singer


3,12 and 6

[Brent]

I hate this format. More sucky people.

[JonathanBelles]

Overall tonight was very good with a few here and there that I would throw out. Simon was a real butthead tonight! Overall for tonight: 8/10

[DESTRUCTION5]

Tatiana Del Toro gets the award for the biggest Fraud and most annoying Female to grace this earth...

[vbhoutex]

Alexis Grace, Anoop Desai, Danny Gokey top three.

Wild Card??????? Michael Sarver, Tattiana Del Toro(based on voice only!!! Otherwise-AAARRRGGHHH!!!!!)
Wild card is not easy for tonight with the three definite standouts, a few definite no's, and the rest just BLAH!!!

My score overall-6.5 out of 10. Not a good lead off show imo.

[tropicana]

i dont think Tatiana is "all there" or she is on drugs. Something about her.

[CajunMama]

Tatiana was really good last night. She's got a really good voice even though she is a bit annoying.

Also, when i see anoops name my mind calls him anoop oggy og.

[southerngale]

A bit?

If I hear that laugh again, I'm going to cut my ears off.



I was glad to see Michael Sarver make it. He's a "local" boy, lives about an hour north of here in Jasper... which happens to be where I evacuated to (not far enough north) for Rita. I thought he was good last night, but liked his style better during Hollywood Week and in his audition. I hope he goes back to that during the Top 12, and I hope he does well.

I think Anoop will make Top 12 via Wildcard.

[Brent]

A bit?

If I hear that laugh again, I'm going to cut my ears off.

I know, my sister and I both can't stand her!

[vbhoutex]

Who made it through? I couldn't watch tonight.

[CajunMama]

Alexis Grace
Danny Gokey
Mike Sarver

[tropicana]

though very beautiful, despite her good "singing voice" (and only singing, not laughing), Tatiana is just not American Idol material.
This is an excerpt from someone who claims to know her personally, and I paraphrase it..
::::It's sad, she truly is a crazy unhinged person and prone to tremendous episodes of anger and rage as well as self destruction. She can be rational and logical and then completely go off the deep end. It's not an act. Though she is a wreck of a person, I personally hope nothing happens to her and she does not hurt herself in the process. Seriously. I dont think any record or TV producer in his right mind should hire her or work with her. She is a walking litigant and a disaster and needs psychological help.:::::

even though she didnt make it last night, she may yet come back to haunt us in the wildcard round.
But just looking at how she intermingled with the other Idols last night after she didn't make it, she was the only one not showing happiness for the ones that did make it. She was so caught up in herself not making it, she didnt consider anyone else in the process. That tells me she cares for no one else but herself.
Well surprise Tatiana, the world does NOT revolve around you...even though you seem genuinely to believe that.
IDOL definetly isnt all about singing, its the whole package..and she is not Idol material....even though she is a phenomenal singer.

-justin-

[lurkey]

2/25/09

#1 too pitchy

commercial already?? grrr . . . goes to chat

#2 sounds out of tune. . . sounded shrill. . that was horrible, on second thought

crap, another bunch of commercials . . . flips over last week's Lost

#3 pitchy start .. . middle . . . and end :|

commercial again *yawns* goes to beat up D5 in chat

#4 well, he can sing and he is memorable . . . I'll give him that. . what? the pitchiness of previous three was baaaaddddd . . my poor ears

*wonders what Paula is taking/smoking*

*back in chat* *kills D5*

#5 agghh . . pitchy . . *echos Brent's comment about how high is Paula tonight* I

#6 eye candy and he can sing . . . he wasn't bad, I mean, look at 1-4

commercial ummmm Lost is on. . decisions, decisions. . .

*flips to Lost real quick to see if shirtless Sawyer is on this week*

#7 finally. . . . some pitchiness and problems with high notes; a Joss Stone vibe

#8 I agree . . boring

#9 alright #7 is waaayyyy better. . .

*commercial* . . Walt is back on Lost and I'm watching this sh. crap. .

#10 sayid look-a-like *checks to make sure dvr is recording LOST*. . . good singer . .. pitch issues, huh? 1-3,5,8, and 9 had pitch issues, lady. . .

#11 she can sing. . .some bad notes though. . . I like #7 better. .

*sighs* people are dying left and right on Lost and I'm stuck watching this

#12 the best tonight

12,10 and 7

*goes to watch Lost*

[Brent]

2/25/09

#1 too pitchy

commercial already?? grrr . . . goes to chat

#2 sounds out of tune. . . sounded shrill

I seriously think these people are deaf. How many times do the judges say song choice is so important each week? Both of them made awful decisions there.

Same for the third..

Nick Mitchell/Norman Gentle, OMG HATE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Is Paula high?

#5, I didn't get it, it was boring.

#6, a decent singer for once. Only took half the show.

#7 Mmmmm, eye candy. Pretty good singing also.

#8 Zzzzzzzzzzz

#9 and 10 Forgettable

#11 Decent

#12 Best of the night by a mile.

[vbhoutex]

Jesse Langseth
Adam Lambert
Allison Ahrhetta(sp?)

[CajunMama]

I'm just now watching. Love the dvr...no commercials!

#2... no one should do coldplay except for coldplay. Viva la vida is my favorite song...he butchered it.

#4... Nick can't go on. Please tell me he can't. Ya think they keep him around for fear of him going nuts and harming them? lol Surely he's got several more personalities that haven't come out yet.

#7...Megan. Liked her singing but what was with her arm movements? She looked goofy.

#12...Adam. The best of the night.

[vbhoutex]

Jesse Langseth
Adam Lambert
Allison Ahrhetta(sp?)

2 out of 3 ain't bad. Kris Allen was the other one I thought was really good. Hopefully we have seen the very last of Nick or whatever he is!!! He has a really good voice, but he is not Idol material. Allison and Adam could end up the final two and imo she blows even him off the stage!!! Like Kara has said, she is just pure raw talent through and through. No 16 year old could have the stage presence she has unless they have been on stage for years(I havd done no research on her background) and her voice is one of the best I have heard in a long long time.

[lurkey]

*yawns*

will this get better . .. mmmm, probably not

#1 meh. . it was ok

<commercial. . .yawn>


#2 this was sucky. . . #1 was a lot better . .

<turns on Tweetdeck to get running commentary from Twitter about AI>

checks on Michael Johns' new song on http://www.votefortheworst.com during commercials

#3 <hits the mute button 30 seconds into the song>

<commercial again *goes to chat to thwap D5*>

#4 she was off-key and pitchy and . . the song was too big for her. .

#5 hmmm . .. he knows this is a song about someone stalking a girl. . . and not a love song, right?

#6 finally, the first one tonight that hasn't caused me to hit the mute button. . .

#7 the drama queen . . .<hits the mute again> he's butchering Meatloaf . . agghh the horror. . .

#8 not as good as 6, cause she had some bad notes, but ok

#9 pretty good. . . there was a bad note, but only one. . .

#10 to paraphase D5 ". . . never attempt Martina . . unless you are her. . ." . . the high notes were not Kendall's friend . .

#11 one of the best tonight .. . just need a little more English diction lessons or just sing in Spanish. . .in fact, if you go want to "out of the box", I would consider singing in Spanish one week

#12 another good one . .

12,11 and 9

12 and 9 definately a toss up between 11 and 6

[Brent]

#1 Much better start than the past two weeks

#2 Well it WAS better. That sucked, and why did she sing the same song again?

#3 Awful and very bizarre

#4 Way too big of a song, what was she thinking?

#5 Horrible

#6 Pretty good

#7 Painful

#8 Pretty good for someone not even in the original top 36

#9 3rd best

#10 Bad

#11 Great, close 2nd

#12 Awesome, best of the night.

[vbhoutex]

12-Lil Rounds-as big as they come!!! Wow!!
9-Scott MacIntyre still has my vote.
11-Jorge Nunez could be a crossover in both english and spanish markets. Let's see if he has it to keep going.
6-Kristen ?-She is right up there too.
1-Von Smith was very good tonight.
6
5
The rest were yuck!!! Especially DRAMA QUEEN!!!!