HurricaneEric wrote:RL3AO wrote:Don't forget option 3 - A weak TS develops and dies in the Caribbean. Think of it as the middle ground.
You're right, I didn't think about that. Still though, would be considered a flop for both in that case, with one flopping on genesis and the other on intensity. Not a good look.
Option 3 is certainly a middle ground, but one that I would clearly view as a "win" for the GFS. Beware of small packages folks. We're talking about only 66 hours from a deepening small low approaching the islands. 90 hours to further deepening down to 1003mb. as this low approaches 60W. All the while, this system approaching from the ESE and a bit further south than most MDR systems. Oh, and dont forget the menacing conditions that typically disrupt low level convergence as tropical systems attempt to approach and develop over the extreme Southeast Caribbean. Yet, doesn't this Look and feel a little familiar? This "model storm" may never see the south side of 1008mb, but remember this: We've seen very small storms that the EURO hardly identified AFTER even forming

Regardless whether S. Florida comes within 500 miles of getting waxed by this system or not, I'm beginning to believe that it is increasingly likely that a very vigorous wave, developing TD, or possibly even a T.S. may well threaten the Windwards in the coming days. "If so", than what does this say about the differing global models and their ability to snoop out meso-scale tropical development? More importantly, such development strikes me as an even more ominous sign of whats to come this year. Perhaps a few other small but quick to develop systems that in August or September might pose an even more menacing threat
In a sort of related question, I'm curious how those of you in your own respective regions have found the NAM (or other mesoscale tools) to perform this year with regards to smaller but intense conditions that ultimately developed? Were the same severe outbreaks this year just as well advertised in advance by the typically reliable EURO (or other global models)?