#1171 Postby Category5Kaiju » Tue Jul 13, 2021 12:59 pm
captainbarbossa19 wrote:toad strangler wrote:captainbarbossa19 wrote:Ah yes. It's that wonderful time of the year when we are in a suppressed state with little to no activity. As usual many "experts" are having doubts about peak season activity. I can tell you that I have seen this year after year. Do NOT trust any model projection a month away. For whatever reason, it seems like when the Atlantic is in a suppressed state, models often like to overextend the length and intensity of the pattern. I cannot tell you how many times I have seen the models show nothing a week before the tropics become active. In this case, I think that there will be an increase in activity towards August. Whether or not we see any hurricanes then remains to be seen, but I do not trust models and have seen them fail countless times when predicting changes with the MJO etc.
I'm not seeing anybody doubt peak season activity. Who are the experts are you talking about? What I do see, are some conflicting output from long range models that are creating discussion such as precip in the MDR or lack thereof but not in a way that is questioning overall season activity. Just chatter. Even around here, I can't remember the last time S2K has been so quiet on the "season cancel" posts in mid July. Most everyone in this hobby sees the active pro seasonal forecasts and understands we are in a suppressed background state right now and probably will be for the rest of the month. I feel that most hobbyists like me are sorta waiting for early to mid August and I'm waiting for that final NOAA update just before that. Meanwhile we keep an eye on SST's and SAL while gleaning as much as we can from the disco going on in pro met social media world in regards to these seasonal and often flawed long range models.
You are right. They are not directly doubting the peak season yet. Give the experts time though. They will come around. It usually happens in early to mid-August whenever the models show nothing for 7-10 days.
You may wonder why I am so critical of them though. It is simply because I know that they do not know everything. I have seen them waver much in the past. Too many people place too much value in their opinions when it is usually just an educated guess. Not every expert is like this, but I see too many post information that is contrary to their original position of a season. For example, one long-range model run comes out that says peak season is quiet, contrary to multiple runs suggesting that a season will be active. Instead of doubting the one run, some "experts" will give too much credit to it and doubt the other runs just because it was the latest run of the model. I would rather stick to an original argument than constantly go back and forth. Doing the latter is not very professional in my opinion. I do not mind if an expert changes his/her opinion, but I consider their opinion much more if it is based on more than one factor over a long period of time.
Also I think it is worth noting that nothing in the tropics is definite and that things can change in the blink of an eye. For example, I have seen in the recent past how a season could feature zero activity one week, only for three named storms to pop up within a span of the next 7 days and surprise many individuals who never expected such to happen. On the other hand, we could have a storm like Delta barreling toward what we all thought was highly likely Category 5 strength, only for it to suddenly succumb to a sudden increase in mid-level shear. There's a lot that goes on and can go on in the tropics, and what I look for and rely on is pretty simple: people who are able to articulate and explain with relevant, well-founded bodies of evidence, in a consistent and direct manner, why they believe certain predictions.
5 likes
Unless explicitly stated, all info in my posts is based on my own opinions and observations. Tropical storms and hurricanes can be extremely dangerous. Do not think you can beat Mother Nature. Refer to an accredited weather research agency or meteorologist if you need to make serious decisions regarding an approaching storm.