Derek Ortt wrote:I'm not sure if the ppt file is online anywhere and I will need to look at it more closely (I'll ask her tomorrow about this project if I go into the office in the morning)
One major problem regarding using QBO is: what is the physical mechanism that causes the correlation? This has yet to be answered by anyone
QBO is a factor WRT to mid-latitude weather (more dominant during the winter months), which creates different synoptic patterns which can or cannot be conducive for stronger tropical cyclones to form ...
TropicalWxWatcher wrote:And I should have added this...
Probability of a Hurricane becoming an Intense Hurricane...
W QBO: 51.4%
E QBO: 23.1%
Your findings suggest that IF the QBO doesn't actually play a direct role, then there MUST be an indirect result of why the chances of an MH are 2 to 1 during W QBO's vs. E QBO's. There are so many other factors to be judged and weighed, but ASSUMING that the findings from TWW are from when QBO datasets have been available (1948-present), almost 60 years of QBO data must play some role, no matter how direct or indirect.
Again, the QBO may or may not play a sufficient role, but there are so many other factors. The weight of the ENSO factor seems to play a strong role. But also remember, since 1995, the ATC has been above average (to seemingly well above average). 2003, the signal was so overwhelming that it frankly was the dominant player, GLOBALLY.... with a lack of a Niño, or Niña, and an E QBO, the CV train got rolling and the overall Azores/Bermuda High setup kept them coming and coming, including Isabel. Sometimes, we have seemingly seen some systems develop tropically, when conditions were only BARELY favorable for development, and I'm NOT afraid to say that the ATC has something to do with that enhancement.
Obviously, something that hasn't been mentioned besides ABV normal SSTA's is the ACTUAL SSTA' anomaly placement, which offers a HUGE indicator of where positive and negative height anomalies will exist in the mid-levels. This ultimately will translate where ridges/troughs will setup and gives indicators in advance (and with a bit of climo thrown in) and can give a MR/LR idea of when an active period, tropically speaking, may commence (Pattern recognition).